Monday, February 6, 2023
No Result
View All Result
  • Media
Support Us
Macdonald-Laurier Institute
  • Home
  • About
    • Who We Are
    • Who Makes MLI Work
    • Tenth Anniversary
    • Jobs
  • Experts
    • Experts Directory
    • In Memoriam
  • Issues
    • Domestic Policy Program
      • Agriculture and Agri-Food
      • Canada’s Political Tradition
      • Economic policy
      • Energy
      • Health Care
      • Innovation
      • Justice
      • Social issues
      • Telecoms
    • Foreign Policy Program
      • Foreign Affairs
      • National Defence
      • National Security
    • Indigenous Affairs Program
  • Projects
    • COVID and after: A mandate for recovery
    • COVID Misery Index
      • Beyond Lockdown
    • Provincial COVID Misery Index
    • Centre for Advancing Canada’s Interests Abroad
      • Dragon at the Door
      • The Eavesdropping Dragon: Huawei
    • An Intellectual Property Strategy for Canada
    • Speak for Ourselves
    • Canada and the Indo-Pacific Initiative
    • DisInfoWatch.org
    • The Transatlantic Program
    • Indigenous Prosperity at a Crossroads
      • Aboriginal Canada and Natural Resources
    • Talkin’ in the Free World with Mariam Memarsadeghi
    • Past Projects
      • Justice Report Card
      • Munk Senior Fellows
      • A Mandate for Canada
      • Confederation Series
      • Fiscal Reform
      • The Canadian Century project
      • Fixing Canadian health care
      • Internal trade
      • From a mandate for change
      • Size of government in Canada
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Past Events
      • MLI Dinners
      • Great Canadian Debates
  • Latest News
  • Libraries
    • Inside Policy Magazine
      • Inside Policy Back Issues
      • Inside Policy Blog
    • Papers
    • Columns
    • Books
    • Commentary
    • Straight Talk
    • Video
    • Multimedia
    • Podcasts
    • Leading Economic Indicator
    • Labour Market Report
    • MLI in the Media
  • Home
  • About
    • Who We Are
    • Who Makes MLI Work
    • Tenth Anniversary
    • Jobs
  • Experts
    • Experts Directory
    • In Memoriam
  • Issues
    • Domestic Policy Program
      • Agriculture and Agri-Food
      • Canada’s Political Tradition
      • Economic policy
      • Energy
      • Health Care
      • Innovation
      • Justice
      • Social issues
      • Telecoms
    • Foreign Policy Program
      • Foreign Affairs
      • National Defence
      • National Security
    • Indigenous Affairs Program
  • Projects
    • COVID and after: A mandate for recovery
    • COVID Misery Index
      • Beyond Lockdown
    • Provincial COVID Misery Index
    • Centre for Advancing Canada’s Interests Abroad
      • Dragon at the Door
      • The Eavesdropping Dragon: Huawei
    • An Intellectual Property Strategy for Canada
    • Speak for Ourselves
    • Canada and the Indo-Pacific Initiative
    • DisInfoWatch.org
    • The Transatlantic Program
    • Indigenous Prosperity at a Crossroads
      • Aboriginal Canada and Natural Resources
    • Talkin’ in the Free World with Mariam Memarsadeghi
    • Past Projects
      • Justice Report Card
      • Munk Senior Fellows
      • A Mandate for Canada
      • Confederation Series
      • Fiscal Reform
      • The Canadian Century project
      • Fixing Canadian health care
      • Internal trade
      • From a mandate for change
      • Size of government in Canada
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Past Events
      • MLI Dinners
      • Great Canadian Debates
  • Latest News
  • Libraries
    • Inside Policy Magazine
      • Inside Policy Back Issues
      • Inside Policy Blog
    • Papers
    • Columns
    • Books
    • Commentary
    • Straight Talk
    • Video
    • Multimedia
    • Podcasts
    • Leading Economic Indicator
    • Labour Market Report
    • MLI in the Media
No Result
View All Result
Macdonald-Laurier Institute

Crowley in Postmedia papers: Liquor control monopolies’ Achilles heel

January 20, 2014
in Columns, In the Media, Latest News
Reading Time: 4 mins read
A A

Writing in the Ottawa Citizen and other Postmedia papers, MLI managing director Brian Lee Crowley detects a potential weakness in the seemingly impregnable provincial liquor monopolies. Like Achilles and his vulnerable heel, provincial liquor control boards could be brought down because provinces don’t have the constitutional authority to create such monopolies, Crowley argues. “With one stroke of a pen, Ottawa could free consumers to buy and sell as they wish, subject to perfectly legal rules about the drinking age and other public health concerns. Based on Alberta’s successful experience with retail privatization, there is no reason for provinces to fear a loss of revenue”, Crowley writes.

Brian Lee Crowley, JANUARY 17, 2014

Ever wonder what an Achilles heel is? It is one of those expressions we all use but whose origins may seem obscure.

Achilles was one of the central characters in Homer’s Iliad. The Greeks’ greatest hero, his mother had been instructed by the gods to dip him as a child in the River Styx. This made him invulnerable, with one tiny exception.

She had to hold on to him somehow and the most convenient handle was his heel. As a result, his heel did not get submerged and remained this formidable warrior’s one tiny point of vulnerability.

One weakness was enough to bring him down, however. Near the end of the siege of Troy a poisoned Trojan arrow struck his heel.

Achilles’ one fatal weakness kept returning to my mind in recent days as I contemplate the future of provincial liquor monopolies across the land.

The arguments in favour of having the provinces get rid of these quaint holdovers of Prohibition and Protestant morality seem to me to be overwhelming. Consumers are overcharged and underserved, taxpayers realize lower returns, governments have huge capital tied up in them at a time when many are drowning in debt, and there is absolutely no need for government to own the distribution and retail system in order to protect the public interest.

Yet like Achilles the provincial liquor monopolies often seem almost invulnerable. Thousands of unionized employees work in them and are vocal and free-spending opponents of privatization. Governments hate change, fear (inaccurately) a loss of revenue and love the employment, control and profile their monopoly creates in communities across their province. And some members of the public are vulnerable to scaremongering about runaway access to booze for underage drinkers and other social ills.

The easiest thing for the average premier to do, then, is nothing. And if the provinces do nothing, surely the liquor monopolies are untouchable.

Except there is this little matter of Achilles heel ….

In the case of the provincial liquor monopolies, the niggling vulnerability is this: provinces actually don’t have the constitutional power to create such monopolies. This was clear at the outset. In the 1920s after our failed experiment with prohibition and provincial liquor commissions were formed to control and regulate the trade in alcohol, everyone was acutely aware that provinces had no power to regulate international or interprovincial commerce.

Now if your province can’t regulate international commerce, for example, by what right does it stop you from simply bypassing it and buying directly from your favourite Scottish distiller or French vintner? The answer is that Ottawa gave them this authority through a 90-year-old law called the Importation of Intoxicating Liquors Act.

That’s right. The provincial liquor monopolies are made possible by Ottawa, not the provinces. If you want the proof, ask yourself who it was that legislated recently to permit Canadians to bring two bottles of wine, one bottle of booze and a dozen beers home from another province? Ottawa. And there wasn’t a thing the provinces could do about it.

Think about that: Ottawa, allegedly the consumer’s best friend, the one government in the country that is supposed to be the unambiguous champion of a single national market, of the freedom of Canadians to buy and sell from each other without hindrance by parochial provinces, is the government that has carved up the national market in alcohol and handed it to the provinces on a silver platter.

With one stroke of a pen, Ottawa could free consumers to buy and sell as they wish, subject to perfectly legal rules about the drinking age and other public health concerns. Based on Alberta’s successful experience with retail privatization, there is no reason for provinces to fear a loss of revenue.

On the contrary, they’d get all the revenue they currently enjoy, but not have to pay over the odds for fancy retail stores and civil servants masquerading as grocery clerks.

Now here’s the second arrow aimed at Achilles’ boozy heel: under the Constitution, Ottawa doesn’t have the power to allow such monopolies either. According to prominent lawyer and constitutionalist Ian Blue, Ottawa’s law falls afoul of Section 121 of the Constitution Act, 1867, that essentially says that the products of one province must be allowed freely into the other provinces.

No exceptions. No federal override. We were creating one open national market in 1867 and the Constitution said so.

These things are never guaranteed, but I think Blue’s argument is correct. If the feds don’t act to tear down this unjustified barrier to Canadians’ individual freedom, a court challenge that saw Ottawa’s law struck down would do the job just as well.

Against the odds invulnerable Achilles fell, then impregnable Troy. Can the provincial liquor monopolies be far behind?

Brian Lee Crowley is the managing director of the Macdonald-Laurier Institute, an independent non-partisan public-policy think-tank in Ottawa. www.macdonaldlaurier.catwitter.com/brianleecrowley

© Copyright (c) The Ottawa Citizen
Previous Post

Audrey Laporte in the Citizen: It’s time to face the economic realities of health care

Next Post

Laporte paper covered by Sun Media

Related Posts

Prioritizing gender identity over sex in prisons endangers female prisoners
Releases

Prioritizing gender identity over sex in prisons endangers female prisoners

February 6, 2023
Greedflation? It’s a government thing: Philip Cross in the Financial Post
Columns

Jagmeet Singh uses confusion about private care to support the status quo: Shawn Whatley in the National Post

February 6, 2023
Stronger enforcement of the Competition Act is better than a dramatic overhaul
Commentary

Stronger enforcement of the Competition Act is better than a dramatic overhaul

February 2, 2023
Next Post

Laporte paper covered by Sun Media

Macdonald-Laurier Institute

323 Chapel Street, Suite #300
Ottawa, Ontario
K1N 7Z2 Canada

613.482.8327

info@macdonaldlaurier.ca
MLI directory

Follow us on

Newsletter Signup

First Name
Last Name
Email Address

Support Us

Support the Macdonald-Laurier Institute to help ensure that Canada is one of the best governed countries in the world. Click below to learn more or become a sponsor.

Support Us

Inside Policy Magazine

  • Current Issue
  • Back Issues
  • Advertising
  • Inside Policy Blog
  • Privacy Policy

© 2021 Macdonald-Laurier Institute. All Rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About
    • Who We Are
    • Who Makes MLI Work
    • Tenth Anniversary
    • Jobs
  • Experts
    • Experts Directory
    • In Memoriam
  • Issues
    • Domestic Policy Program
      • Agriculture and Agri-Food
      • Canada’s Political Tradition
      • Economic policy
      • Energy
      • Health Care
      • Innovation
      • Justice
      • Social issues
      • Telecoms
    • Foreign Policy Program
      • Foreign Affairs
      • National Defence
      • National Security
    • Indigenous Affairs Program
  • Projects
    • COVID and after: A mandate for recovery
    • COVID Misery Index
      • Beyond Lockdown
    • Provincial COVID Misery Index
    • Centre for Advancing Canada’s Interests Abroad
      • Dragon at the Door
      • The Eavesdropping Dragon: Huawei
    • An Intellectual Property Strategy for Canada
    • Speak for Ourselves
    • Canada and the Indo-Pacific Initiative
    • DisInfoWatch.org
    • The Transatlantic Program
    • Indigenous Prosperity at a Crossroads
      • Aboriginal Canada and Natural Resources
    • Talkin’ in the Free World with Mariam Memarsadeghi
    • Past Projects
      • Justice Report Card
      • Munk Senior Fellows
      • A Mandate for Canada
      • Confederation Series
      • Fiscal Reform
      • The Canadian Century project
      • Fixing Canadian health care
      • Internal trade
      • From a mandate for change
      • Size of government in Canada
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Past Events
      • MLI Dinners
      • Great Canadian Debates
  • Latest News
  • Libraries
    • Inside Policy Magazine
      • Inside Policy Back Issues
      • Inside Policy Blog
    • Papers
    • Columns
    • Books
    • Commentary
    • Straight Talk
    • Video
    • Multimedia
    • Podcasts
    • Leading Economic Indicator
    • Labour Market Report
    • MLI in the Media

© 2021 Macdonald-Laurier Institute. All Rights reserved.

IDEAS CHANGE THE WORLD!Have the latest Canadian thought leadership delivered straight to your inbox.
First Name
Last Name
Email address

No thanks, I’m not interested.