Friday, June 2, 2023
No Result
View All Result
  • Media
Support Us
Macdonald-Laurier Institute
  • Home
  • About
    • Who We Are
    • Who Makes MLI Work
    • Tenth Anniversary
  • Experts
    • Experts Directory
    • In Memoriam
  • Issues
    • Domestic Policy Program
      • Agriculture and Agri-Food
      • Canada’s Political Tradition
      • Economic policy
      • Health Care
      • Innovation
      • Justice
      • Social issues
      • Telecoms
    • Energy Policy Program
      • Energy
      • Environment
    • Foreign Policy Program
      • Foreign Affairs
      • National Defence
      • National Security
    • Indigenous Affairs Program
  • Projects
    • The Great Energy Crisis
    • Centre for Advancing Canada’s Interests Abroad
    • Dragon at the Door
    • Canada and the Indo-Pacific Initiative
    • The Transatlantic Program
    • DisInfoWatch.org
    • An Intellectual Property Strategy for Canada
    • Competition Policy in Canada
    • Speak for Ourselves
    • Justice Report Card
    • COVID Misery Index
      • Provincial COVID Misery Index
      • Beyond Lockdown
      • COVID and after: A mandate for recovery
    • Indigenous Prosperity at a Crossroads
      • Aboriginal Canada and Natural Resources
    • Past Projects
      • The Eavesdropping Dragon: Huawei
      • Talkin’ in the Free World with Mariam Memarsadeghi
      • Munk Senior Fellows
      • A Mandate for Canada
      • Confederation Series
      • Fiscal Reform
      • The Canadian Century project
      • Fixing Canadian health care
      • Internal trade
      • From a mandate for change
      • Size of government in Canada
      • Straight Talk
      • Labour Market Report
      • Leading Economic Indicator
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Past Events
      • MLI Dinners
      • Great Canadian Debates
  • Latest News
  • Libraries
    • Inside Policy Magazine
      • Inside Policy Online
      • Inside Policy Back Issues
    • Papers
    • Commentary
    • Columns
    • Books
    • Video
    • Podcasts
  • Home
  • About
    • Who We Are
    • Who Makes MLI Work
    • Tenth Anniversary
  • Experts
    • Experts Directory
    • In Memoriam
  • Issues
    • Domestic Policy Program
      • Agriculture and Agri-Food
      • Canada’s Political Tradition
      • Economic policy
      • Health Care
      • Innovation
      • Justice
      • Social issues
      • Telecoms
    • Energy Policy Program
      • Energy
      • Environment
    • Foreign Policy Program
      • Foreign Affairs
      • National Defence
      • National Security
    • Indigenous Affairs Program
  • Projects
    • The Great Energy Crisis
    • Centre for Advancing Canada’s Interests Abroad
    • Dragon at the Door
    • Canada and the Indo-Pacific Initiative
    • The Transatlantic Program
    • DisInfoWatch.org
    • An Intellectual Property Strategy for Canada
    • Competition Policy in Canada
    • Speak for Ourselves
    • Justice Report Card
    • COVID Misery Index
      • Provincial COVID Misery Index
      • Beyond Lockdown
      • COVID and after: A mandate for recovery
    • Indigenous Prosperity at a Crossroads
      • Aboriginal Canada and Natural Resources
    • Past Projects
      • The Eavesdropping Dragon: Huawei
      • Talkin’ in the Free World with Mariam Memarsadeghi
      • Munk Senior Fellows
      • A Mandate for Canada
      • Confederation Series
      • Fiscal Reform
      • The Canadian Century project
      • Fixing Canadian health care
      • Internal trade
      • From a mandate for change
      • Size of government in Canada
      • Straight Talk
      • Labour Market Report
      • Leading Economic Indicator
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Past Events
      • MLI Dinners
      • Great Canadian Debates
  • Latest News
  • Libraries
    • Inside Policy Magazine
      • Inside Policy Online
      • Inside Policy Back Issues
    • Papers
    • Commentary
    • Columns
    • Books
    • Video
    • Podcasts
No Result
View All Result
Macdonald-Laurier Institute

Beyond the Indian Act: Lessons learned from independent land management by First Nations

Any effort to reform the Indian Act first requires asserting the primacy of Indigenous treaty rights.

April 28, 2023
in Indigenous Affairs papers, Indigenous Affairs Program, Ken Coates, Papers
Reading Time: 3 mins read
A A

By Ken Coates and Britt Baumann
April 28, 2023

PDF of paper

Executive Summary

The Indian Act has asserted control over the lives of First Nations peoples since 1876. The Act codified the management of reserve lands, and it is the primary legislation that defines First Nations rights within Canada, such as treaty rights and legislative privileges. Yet the Act is seriously flawed.

Originally designed to facilitate assimilation, those living under it have been subjected to gender discrimination, racial segregation, the suppression of cultural activities, and mandatory attendance at Canada’s Indian residential or day schools. Under the Indian Act, First Nations need permission from the minister of Crown-Indigenous Relations even for such routine processes as the allotment of reserve land to a band member or the transfer of land between band members. Additionally, ministerial approval is also required for transactions involving non-band members regarding the lease of reserve land for residential or commercial use, or the simple issuance of a permit for a power or water line.

For several decades, it was the intention of both First Nations and the federal government to improve upon the Indian Act and to facilitate sectoral self-governance. The organized efforts to increase First Nation control over their own land started in 1991 when a group of 13 First Nations from across Canada developed a proposal that would allow First Nations to withdraw from those provisions of the Indian Act that concern land management. The intent was to replace the Act’s land centralized and cumbersome land management regime with a so-called “land code” of the First Nations’ making.

The negotiations came to fruition in 1999 when the government of Canada passed the First Nations Land Management Act (FNLMA), which enabled several dozen First Nations to independently establish and administer land codes that conform to First Nation values, traditions, and community goals. Often described as a steppingstone for First Nations seeking to reclaim their autonomy, some observers consider the FNLMA to have been an important and effective pathway for exiting the Indian Act.

The full economic impact of the FNLMA is yet to be determined. The rise of third-party partnerships has become increasingly important to First Nations, and the ease of operations under a FNLM regime has led to an increase in the number of businesses owned or partially owned by external partners. As one example of the decrease in bureaucracy under the FNLMA, under the Indian Act it took an average of 584 days to complete an approval for a permit or lease; under the FNLM regime the average approval time has dropped to only 17 days.

That said, enthusiasm for the FNLMA has not been universal, and there was extensive criticism of the legislation. For some critics, the FNLMA was a highway to reserve marketization, which would open reserve lands to market forces. To the strongest opponents, such a measure represents a renewed form of colonialism where third-party business is given the opportunity to gain an economic interest from First Nation lands. While many First Nations benefited from their decision to make use of the FNLMA, these benefits were limited and unequally shared among the participating First Nations. Furthermore, participation in the FNLMA regime has not been universally accessible or desirable and hence the FNLMA was deemed to be inadequate. Ultimately, in December 2022 the FNMLA was repealed in favour of the more streamlined and less regimented Framework Agreement on First Nation Land Management Act (FAFNLMA).

As a nation, Canada has struggled with the reality that First Nations people tend to understand the concept of private property rights differently than do the proponents of private property and market liberalism. First Nations obviously value and wish to preserve their constitutionally enshrined rights to the land. To be successful, any amendment or other legislation pertaining to the Indian Act must proclaim First Nation treaty rights as inalienable. Recognition of Indigenous title to land is the linchpin that maintains the relationship between Canada and the First Nations.

Policy proposals that do not respect Indigenous rights will not be supported by First Nations people and ignoring the importance of Indigenous rights will lead to disruption in the relationship between First Nations peoples and Canada.

Tags: Britt Baumannindigenous affairsIndigenous land managementKen Coates
Previous Post

Confronting authoritarian challenges together: MLI hosts roundtable with Visegrad Group delegation

Next Post

It’s time to get ‘Beyond the Indian Act’

Related Posts

Don’t blame Indigenous people for Calgary cancelling July 1st fireworks: Melissa Mbarki in the National Post
Columns

Don’t blame Indigenous people for Calgary cancelling July 1st fireworks: Melissa Mbarki in the National Post

May 25, 2023
Counterproductive Competition Act reforms may actually hamper competition
Papers

Staying the course: Why competition law should remain focused on consumer welfare standards

May 25, 2023
Webinar panel video: Repudiating the Doctrine of Discovery – A symbolic act or a new beginning with Indigenous Peoples?
Past Events

Webinar panel video: Repudiating the Doctrine of Discovery – A symbolic act or a new beginning with Indigenous Peoples?

May 18, 2023
Next Post

It’s time to get ‘Beyond the Indian Act’

Newsletter Signup

Follow us on

Macdonald-Laurier Institute

323 Chapel Street, Suite #300
Ottawa, Ontario, K1N 7Z2 Canada

613.482.8327

info@macdonaldlaurier.ca
MLI directory

Support Us

Support the Macdonald-Laurier Institute to help ensure that Canada is one of the best governed countries in the world. Click below to learn more or become a sponsor.

Support Us

  • Inside Policy Magazine
  • Annual Reports
  • Jobs
  • Privacy Policy

© 2021 Macdonald-Laurier Institute. All Rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About
    • Who We Are
    • Who Makes MLI Work
    • Tenth Anniversary
  • Experts
    • Experts Directory
    • In Memoriam
  • Issues
    • Domestic Policy Program
      • Agriculture and Agri-Food
      • Canada’s Political Tradition
      • Economic policy
      • Health Care
      • Innovation
      • Justice
      • Social issues
      • Telecoms
    • Energy Policy Program
      • Energy
      • Environment
    • Foreign Policy Program
      • Foreign Affairs
      • National Defence
      • National Security
    • Indigenous Affairs Program
  • Projects
    • The Great Energy Crisis
    • Centre for Advancing Canada’s Interests Abroad
    • Dragon at the Door
    • Canada and the Indo-Pacific Initiative
    • The Transatlantic Program
    • DisInfoWatch.org
    • An Intellectual Property Strategy for Canada
    • Competition Policy in Canada
    • Speak for Ourselves
    • Justice Report Card
    • COVID Misery Index
      • Provincial COVID Misery Index
      • Beyond Lockdown
      • COVID and after: A mandate for recovery
    • Indigenous Prosperity at a Crossroads
      • Aboriginal Canada and Natural Resources
    • Past Projects
      • The Eavesdropping Dragon: Huawei
      • Talkin’ in the Free World with Mariam Memarsadeghi
      • Munk Senior Fellows
      • A Mandate for Canada
      • Confederation Series
      • Fiscal Reform
      • The Canadian Century project
      • Fixing Canadian health care
      • Internal trade
      • From a mandate for change
      • Size of government in Canada
      • Straight Talk
      • Labour Market Report
      • Leading Economic Indicator
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Past Events
      • MLI Dinners
      • Great Canadian Debates
  • Latest News
  • Libraries
    • Inside Policy Magazine
      • Inside Policy Online
      • Inside Policy Back Issues
    • Papers
    • Commentary
    • Columns
    • Books
    • Video
    • Podcasts

© 2021 Macdonald-Laurier Institute. All Rights reserved.

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

Privacy Preference Center

Consent Management

Necessary

Advertising

Analytics

Other